Here's the deal with pumpkin french toast recipe - I've thrown away at least forty bucks on soggy disasters trying to figure out this pumpkin french toast recipe. Made every mistake with pumpkin french toast: too much pumpkin created orange soup, not enough spices meant bland mush, high heat burned the outside while middles stayed raw. Spent nearly a year testing this pumpkin french toast recipe, plus one awful fall brunch where I served basically wet bread to guests. Finally cracked the code on this pumpkin french toast. Now this pumpkin french toast recipe comes out right every time.
Why You'll Love This Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
This pumpkin french toast recipe fixed a problem I didn't know I had - wanting cozy fall flavors without complicated recipes or weird ingredients.
What Actually Works: This easy pumpkin french toast gives you custardy inside with caramelized crispy edges because the pumpkin-to-egg ratio is balanced. Real pumpkin spice flavor that tastes like actual fall. My husband usually grabs a granola bar and runs, but when I make this pumpkin spice french toast, he suddenly has time for breakfast. This pumpkin french toast recipe works just as well on a Tuesday as it does for weekend company.
Why Most Recipes Suck: Every other pumpkin french toast recipe I tried said "throw pumpkin puree in your eggs" without explaining that too much makes custard watery. The bread won't brown, stays pale and sad. This best pumpkin french toast method explains the why behind each step.
What changed everything: realizing less pumpkin gives better pumpkin flavor. When you use the right amount in your pumpkin french toast, the taste comes through without making custard too thin. Heavy cream makes it custardy instead of eggy. Medium heat gives gorgeous golden-brown color with crispy edges. Once I started paying attention to texture, my pumpkin french toast recipe went from embarrassing to something people actually request.
Jump to:
- Why You'll Love This Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
- What You'll Need for Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
- How to Make Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
- Top Tip
- Ingredient Substitutions & Variations
- Storage and Reuse Instructions
- What to Serve With Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
- My Expensive Education
- FAQ
- More Recipes You'll Love
- Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
- Related
- Pairing
What You'll Need for Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
This pumpkin breakfast recipe uses stuff you probably already have if you do any fall baking. Not asking you to track down some obscure pumpkin variety or expensive artisan bread for pumpkin french toast recipe.
Thick bread is key - brioche is my favorite because it's already a little sweet and rich, but challah works great too. Even thick-cut store brand "Texas toast" style bread from the regular grocery store does the job. Pure pumpkin puree matters - not the pumpkin pie filling that's loaded with sugar and spices already.
Main Ingredients
- Thick-sliced bread
- Large eggs
- Pumpkin puree
- Whole milk
- Heavy cream
- Granulated sugar
- Vanilla extract
- Ground cinnamon
- Pumpkin pie spice
- Salt
- Butter
Optional Add-ins
- Cream cheese filling
- Chopped pecans or walnuts
- Chocolate chips
- Orange zest
- Ground nutmeg
Topping and Serving
- Maple syrup
- Whipped cream
- Powdered sugar
- Caramel sauce
- Extra butter
Finishing Touches
Real maple syrup (not the fake stuff) makes a huge difference with this fall french toast recipe. Homemade whipped cream takes it over the top if you're feeling fancy. I've seen people do candied pecans on top which is extra but also delicious. Everything else you need is in the recipe card.
How to Make Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
This pumpkin french toast recipe works when you actually do the steps right instead of skipping around or "improving" things before you understand why they work.
Mix up the pumpkin custard
- Grab a shallow bowl or pie plate - needs to be wide enough to fit your bread
- Crack in the eggs and whisk them up first for pumpkin french toast recipe
- Add your pumpkin puree - measure it, don't just eyeball
- Pour in milk, heavy cream, and sugar
- Dump in vanilla, cinnamon, pumpkin pie spice, and a pinch of salt
- Whisk this whole thing until it's completely smooth - no pumpkin chunks floating around
- Let it sit a minute while you heat up your pan so the spices wake up
- Should look like orangey custard, pourable but not watery for easy pumpkin french toast
Soak the bread properly
- If you're using a whole loaf, cut nice thick slices - about ¾ inch minimum
- Dip each slice in that pumpkin custard for pumpkin french toast
- Let it hang out there for like 20-30 seconds per side
- You want it soaked through but still holding together, not falling apart in your hands
- Under-soak and you get dry centers that taste like regular bread in pumpkin spice french toast
- Over-soak and it turns into orange mush that breaks when you try to flip it
- There's a sweet spot where the bread's saturated but sturdy - you'll feel it
Cook it without burning
- Get your butter melting in a big skillet over medium heat - not medium-high, just medium
- Wait till the butter's foaming but hasn't started browning yet
- Lay your soaked bread in there for pumpkin french toast recipe
- Leave it alone for 3-4 minutes - don't keep checking and peeking
- Flip when you see the edges getting golden and the top is starting to look set
- Cook another 3-4 minutes on the second side for best pumpkin french toast
- If you crank the heat trying to speed this up, you'll burn the outside and have raw egg custard in the middle - I know because I've done it
- Keep adding fresh butter between batches
- Stick finished pieces in a 200°F oven to stay warm while you cook the rest
Get it on the plate fast
- Move the cooked french toast to plates right away
- Drop some butter on top while it's hot so it melts down
- Pour over your maple syrup - be generous, this isn't diet food
- Whipped cream if you're into that for pumpkin breakfast recipe
- Little shake of powdered sugar makes it look prettier
- Eat it immediately while it's still hot
- This fall french toast recipe gets sad and soggy if it sits around
Good pumpkin french toast has that perfect crispy-soft thing happening, real pumpkin spice flavor that tastes like fall actually arrived, and gets the outside caramelized without overcooking the custardy middle.
Top Tip
Stop drowning your pumpkin french toast recipe custard in pumpkin puree. Biggest mistake I made with pumpkin french toast - dumping in way too much pumpkin thinking more = more flavor. Nope. Too much pumpkin makes custard thin and watery, bread stays pale instead of browning, tastes weirdly bland despite the orange color. The magic ratio for pumpkin french toast is ¼ cup pumpkin puree per 4 eggs. That gives actual pumpkin taste without screwing up the texture.
Other thing - medium heat isn't a suggestion for pumpkin french toast, it's required. I used to crank it high thinking I'd save time, ended up with burnt outsides and raw egg middles every time. Medium heat gives everything time to cook through while building that gorgeous golden crust on your pumpkin french toast recipe. And don't skip the heavy cream - that's what makes pumpkin french toast custardy instead of just scrambled eggs
Ingredient Substitutions & Variations
Real life means sometimes you're missing stuff and need to improvise with pumpkin french toast recipe. No brioche? Challah works, thick Texas toast works, honestly even regular sandwich bread can work if it's all you've got, though texture won't be quite as good. Out of heavy cream? Use all milk - won't be as rich but still tastes fine.
Ways to change up pumpkin french toast - stuff it with cream cheese by spreading between two slices before dunking in custard. Throw chocolate chips in the custard if you're making it for kids. Cut back sugar and add fresh sage for a weird but surprisingly good savory version. Add a splash of bourbon to the custard for grown-up brunch. Turn the whole thing into a casserole where you layer everything in a baking dish instead of cooking individual slices. Core concept stays the same - balanced custard ratios and proper heat is what makes pumpkin spice french toast actually work instead of just looking pumpkin-colored.
Storage and Reuse Instructions
This pumpkin french toast recipe keeps in the fridge maybe 2-3 days but honestly it's never as good as fresh. If you've got leftovers, throw them in an airtight container. Best way to reheat is in a toaster oven at 350°F for 5-7 minutes so you get some crispiness back. Microwave works if you're desperate but makes them kind of rubbery.
Freezing works okay for up to 2 months if you wrap individual slices in plastic wrap and stick them in a freezer bag. Reheat from frozen in the toaster oven at 350°F for 10-12 minutes. Real talk though - pumpkin french toast is one of those things that really should be eaten fresh. That crispy outside and custardy inside just doesn't survive storage well. Make what you'll actually eat instead of making extras thinking you'll reheat them.
What to Serve With Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
This pumpkin breakfast recipe is pretty sweet on its own but having some savory stuff on the side balances it out. Crispy bacon is classic - that salty-sweet combo just works. Breakfast sausage adds protein if you're feeding people who'll be hungry again in an hour without it.
If you want lighter sides with fall french toast recipe - fruit salad cuts through all that richness. Greek yogurt gives you protein without being heavy. Even just a handful of arugula with lemon juice works for brunch situations. Drink-wise, coffee obviously, but apple cider or a pumpkin spice latte really commits to the fall theme with your pumpkin french toast recipe.
My Expensive Education
Year ago I was awful at making pumpkin french toast recipe. Worst disaster was volunteering to host fall brunch for my book club - ten women I wanted to impress. Saw pumpkin french toast all over Pinterest, tried it once at home, decided I could handle making it for a crowd.
Morning of brunch, got overexcited and kept adding more pumpkin puree to the custard without measuring. Big mistake. The custard came out so watery that when I dipped the bread, it soaked through and fell apart. Wouldn't brown properly, just sat in the pan pale and sad. What I served was basically limp orange bread that tasted like wet cardboard. Humiliating watching them politely take tiny bites.
Soon as everyone left, I googled what went wrong with pumpkin french toast recipe. Too much pumpkin dilutes the eggs so custard can't set or brown. Learned ratios matter. Learned medium heat is essential.
Spent the next thirty weekends testing pumpkin french toast. Measured precisely. Tried different pumpkin amounts until I found that ¼ cup per 4 eggs sweet spot. Experimented with heat levels. Now I make this best pumpkin french toast recipe every weekend through fall and those same book club women asked me to make it again next year. Difference between faking it and understanding is the difference between garbage and something people actually want to eat.
FAQ
Can you make pumpkin french toast the night before?
Mix up your pumpkin custard the night before and stick it in the fridge - that's totally fine and saves morning time. But don't soak the bread until right before you're ready to cook. Pre-soaking bread overnight turns it into orange mush that falls apart when you try to move it. For pumpkin french toast recipe that actually works, prep your custard ahead if you want, but dip and cook fresh. Only exception is if you're specifically making overnight pumpkin french toast casserole where the long soak is the whole point. Regular easy pumpkin french toast cooked slice-by-slice needs fresh soaking right before cooking.
What kind of bread is best for pumpkin french toast?
Brioche or challah are hands-down the best for pumpkin french toast recipe because they're already rich and eggy, plus they're dense enough to soak up custard without turning to mush. Get thick slices - about ¾ to 1 inch. Day-old bread actually works better than super fresh because it absorbs more. If you can't find brioche or challah, thick Texas toast from the grocery store bread aisle works fine for pumpkin spice french toast.
How do you make pumpkin french toast extra fluffy?
Heavy cream in the custard is step one for fluffy pumpkin french toast - makes it way more tender than using all milk. If you really want to go extra, separate your eggs and beat the whites till they're foamy, then fold them into the pumpkin custard mixture - creates this super light texture in the best pumpkin french toast. Don't smash down on the bread while it's cooking, and flip gently so you don't deflate that custardy center.
Can you use canned pumpkin puree for pumpkin french toast?
Absolutely, canned pumpkin puree is what I use every time for pumpkin french toast recipe. Just double-check you're grabbing pure pumpkin puree (ingredients should say just "pumpkin") and NOT pumpkin pie filling which already has sugar and spices mixed in. Pure puree lets you control sweetness and spicing yourself in your pumpkin breakfast recipe. Canned is consistent and convenient - way easier than roasting an actual pumpkin and scraping it out. One regular 15-ounce can gives you enough for multiple batches of easy pumpkin french toast.
More Recipes You'll Love
This pumpkin french toast recipe is perfect for cozy fall mornings when you want breakfast that feels special! When I'm making this pumpkin french toast and want more make-ahead options, my Blueberry French Toast Casserole Recipe is a game-changer - prep the night before with berries and cream cheese, then just bake while you drink coffee. For something savory to balance the sweetness of pumpkin french toast recipe, my Baked Feta Eggs give you creamy Mediterranean flavors with runny yolks in 15 minutes. And when you need portable breakfast as delicious as this pumpkin french toast, my Sausage Egg Breakfast Roll wraps flaky pastry with cheesy eggs and sausage for grab-and-go mornings.
Pumpkin French Toast Recipe
Equipment
- 1 Large shallow bowl or pie plate For mixing pumpkin custard and soaking bread
- 1 Whisk To blend pumpkin custard mixture smooth
- 1 Large skillet or griddle For cooking french toast
- 1 Spatula For flipping french toast slices
- 1 Measuring cups and spoons Essential for proper pumpkin ratio
Ingredients
- 8 slices thick bread
- 4 large eggs
- ¼ cup pumpkin puree
- ½ cup whole milk
- ¼ cup heavy cream
- 2 tablespoons granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- ½ teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
- ¼ teaspoon salt
- 3 tablespoons butter
- Cream cheese
- ¼ cup chopped pecans or walnuts
- 2 tablespoons chocolate chips
- 1 teaspoon orange zest
- Ground nutmeg
- Maple syrup
- Whipped cream
- Powdered sugar
- Caramel sauce
- Extra butter
Instructions
- In a large shallow bowl or pie plate, crack the eggs and whisk them together. Add pumpkin puree (measure exactly ¼ cup), whole milk, heavy cream, and granulated sugar. Whisk in vanilla extract, cinnamon, pumpkin pie spice, and salt. Mix until completely smooth with no pumpkin lumps. Let sit for 1 minute to allow spices to bloom.
- If using a whole loaf, cut bread into thick slices about ¾ inch. Dip each bread slice into the pumpkin custard mixture. Let soak for 20-30 seconds per side. The bread should be saturated but still holding together, not falling apart.
- Heat butter in a large skillet or griddle over medium heat. Wait until butter is melted and foaming but hasn't started browning yet. Place soaked bread slices in the buttered pan.
- Cook for 3-4 minutes without moving them. Flip when edges are golden and top looks set. Cook another 3-4 minutes on the second side until deep golden brown. Add fresh butter between batches. Keep finished pieces warm in a 200°F oven while cooking the rest.
- Transfer cooked french toast to plates immediately. Top with a pat of butter so it melts down. Pour warm maple syrup generously over the top. Add whipped cream if desired. Dust with powdered sugar for prettier presentation. Serve immediately while hot.
Notes
Nutrition
Related
Looking for other recipes like this? Try these:
Pairing
These are my favorite dishes to serve with Pumpkin French Toast Recipe:
Leave a Reply